Oyster Pearl Rating

  • Award-Winning

What's Your Style?

    See More

    Locations

      See More

      Amenities

        See More

        Long Island Hotels

          46 Hotels Found
          1. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            The 109-room, upscale Gurney's Montauk stands out among Hamptons hotels, quite literally: It's one of the largest resorts in the area, and it also has the best beachfront location. No other Montauk resort compares in terms of features, and no Hamptons resort can match its truly terrific, and stretch…
          2. The East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast
            East Hampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Luxury
            • Romantic
            This elegant B&B in East Hampton is exactly what its name suggests: a house full of art. It was designed and decorated by the owners, Michael and Rosalind, who combine mutual talents in art and hospitality. There are only four rooms for rent, but there are all the amenities of a larger property, an…
          3. Oheka Castle
            Huntington, Long Island, New York
            • Boutique
            • Business
            • Historic
            • Luxury
            • Romantic
            Oheka Castle, built in the 1920s as the second largest private residence in the U.S., is a magnificent chateau-style property about an hour from New York City. It’s the country’s top wedding venue, and one of the most striking properties on the East Coast. It features 32 individually decorated rooms…
          4. Montauk Manor
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Historic
            • Value
            Built in 1927 as a getaway for the rich and famous, Montauk Manor is a Tudor Revival-style hotel perched on a grassy hilltop overlooking the water. This three-pearl 12-acre property has a quiet vibe and is just a short drive (or free shuttle trip) from town. The 140 privately owned condo-style units…
          5. Allegria Hotel
            Long Beach, Long Island, New York
            • Beachfront
            • Business
            • Luxury
            • Party
            • Romantic
            The Allegria Hotel is a chic 143-room boutique delivering a dose of Miami style right on the Long Beach boardwalk. It draws both trendy Manhattanites looking for a convenient beach getaway and business travelers attending corporate events on-site. Big rooms have light, airy decor, plush beds, and in…
          6. The Palms Hotel Fire Island
            Ocean Beach, Fire Island, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Romantic
            This lovely, 27-room boutique hotel is located just minutes from the ferry landing in the Ocean Beach section of the island, and is best described as a collection of lodgings versus a hotel, since there are rooms in the main hotel as well as separate cottages, bungalows, suites, and efficiencies. In…
          7. Driftwood on the Ocean
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            Nestled on a quiet stretch of sand in Montauk, Driftwood on the Ocean has 52 privately owned condo units. The Studios and One- and Two-Bedroom Suites at this mid-range property range from pleasant beach-cottage decor to dated-looking units whose furnishings have seen better days. All have or and or…
          8. Royal Atlantic Beach Resorts
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            The best thing about the lower-middle-range, 150-room Royal Atlantic Beach Resorts is the location of its main building, which is directly on the beachfront and within walking distance of Montauk town center. Guest rooms on the ground floor have direct access to the beautiful 1.61 mile-long sandy is…
          9. Ocean Dunes Resort & Residences
            Amagansett, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Romantic
            This condo beach property has 32 units in a two-story, motel-style building, surrounded by flower boxes, and property high points include the outdoor pool, private beach access, and location within walking distance of the hamlet of Amagansett. All units come with a kitchen, though they range in and…
          10. Mill House Inn
            East Hampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Luxury
            • Romantic
            This historic home turned bed-and-breakfast in East Hampton is meticulously maintained and decorated. Although it's just a short walk from the village center, it remains a hidden gem (one that stays open year round). The owners, Gary and Sylvia, have included their personal touches in the 10 rooms a…
          11. Sole East Resort
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Luxury
            • Party
            • Romantic
            This American Tudor-style hotel in Montauk is a summer hot spot that maintains an essence of “cool” without pretension. The 67 rooms and suites have a surf-chic vibe and appeal to the Manhattan set with amenities such as pillow-top beds, free Wi-Fi, and Aveda products. Though not directly on the the…
          12. Surf Club Resort
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            There are 92 individually decorated units at this three-pearl Montauk property, one of the most popular vacation spots in town. The peaceful location on eight-and-a-half natural acres has direct beach access, and is only a five-minute walk to all the shops and restaurants of downtown Montauk. The a…
          13. Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Child-Friendly
            • Historic
            Overlooking Lake Montauk, this family-friendly resort is a classic summer getaway with views of the attached marina, bobbing with boats, and a white lighthouse. Its 107 rooms, suites, and villas are nicely decorated in nautical style, and equipped with air-conditioning, flat-screen LED TVs, and the…
          14. The Montauk Beach House
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Party
            • Romantic
            The Montauk Beach House is a small, four-pearl boutique hotel with 33 rooms, known for its lively party scene. Though it doesn’t have a beachside location, the two outdoor pools are the central hub of the property -- this is where guests congregate not only to swim and sunbathe, but also to mingle a…
          15. Hyatt Place Long Island East End
            Riverhead, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            Hyatt Place Long Island East End, a mid-range chain hotel, is located between the north and south forks of Long Island next to the Long Island Aquarium. Its 100 spacious rooms have views of the Peconic River, a small marina, or its outdoor pool. The property also includes an indoor pool, a 24-hour a…
          16. The Maidstone Hotel
            East Hampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Historic
            • Luxury
            • Romantic
            This historic yet chic property in the center of East Hampton appeals to the stylish Hamptonite crowd with three cottages and 16 rooms and suites, all decorated in Scandinavian design. Owned by a Swedish-American hotelier, Maidstone is just steps from the village and a bike ride to the beach (with a…
          17. Sea Crest on the Ocean
            Amagansett, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            Smack dab between Amagansett and Montauk, the Sea Crest on the Ocean resort is a two-level condo property containing studio, one-, two-, or three-bedroom units. Studios contain efficiency kitchens, and all others have full kitchens. Units vary greatly in decor depending on owner, so ask for a when a…
          18. The Hedges Inn
            East Hampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Historic
            • Romantic
            This charming East Hampton inn is a cozy gem. Built in 1870, it still retains its original Victorian charm while also offering modern comforts such as free Wi-Fi, contemporary bathrooms, and flat-screen TVs. With a total of 12 unique rooms, decorated mostly in calming and seaside-appropriate whites…
          19. Hero Beach Club
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            The two-pearl Hero Beach Club is ideal for couples and families who wish to be near the beach and walking distance to town. Rooms have a range of colorful styles, but all come with flat-screen TVs, mini-fridges, coffeemakers, and balconies or porches. Some rooms have kitchenettes, while Efficiency a…
          20. Beachcomber Resort At Montauk
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            There are 88 individually decorated rooms at this three-pearl Montauk property. Many guests come back time and time again for a peaceful vacation, as the resort is in a quiet area that's a 15-minute walk from downtown Montauk, with a beautiful beach just across the street. All rooms have a full and…
          21. The Ocean Resort Inn
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Value
            The Ocean Resort Inn is in the quasi-laid back surfing town of Montauk, Long Island, an area with a bit of authenticity in the otherwise tony Hamptons. This 26-room, lower-middle-range property is a throwback to a time when American seaside resorts were more about location than frills. The inn faces…
          22. Montauk Blue Hotel
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Value
            Renovated in 2014, the Montauk Blue Hotel is a modest budget property with clean, modern rooms and a great location right on the beach. Although the hotel has few on-site amenities, it's close to a number of shops and some rooms lead right out onto the sand. In addition to free parking and free the…
          23. Capri
            Southampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Business
            • Party
            This 30-room boutique hotel in Southampton is geared toward the cool crowd with its famed restaurant and designer duds sold on-site. Live DJs keep the pool party scene going until late hours on Friday and Saturday -- but the place becomes an oasis of calm midweek. Rooms are expensive, but they the a…
          24. Beach Plum Resort
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            There are 29 individually-decorated rooms at this three-pearl, condo-style Montauk property. It’s a popular choice for a peaceful vacation, as the resort's quiet setting is a 15-minute walk from downtown Montauk. There's also a beautiful beach just across the street. All rooms have air-conditioning…
          25. Hartman's Briney Breezes Motel
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            The family-friendly Hartman’s Briney Breezes Motel is a small, welcoming property with a great location by the water and a few minutes from the Montauk town center. Owned by a local couple who live on the property, the hotel is casual and comfortable, offering thoughtful amenities including free a a…
          26. Ocean Surf Resort
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            The main highlight of this budget property is its beachfront location that's within a five-minute walk of restaurants and the Hampton Jitney stop. It's a simple and modest (but clean) property, and it doesn't offer many features beyond a gorgeous outdoor pool with an attractive sundeck and sweeping…
          27. Haven Montauk
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            There are 27 rooms at this stylish two-and-a-half-pearl boutique motel. North of downtown Montauk, the hotel's quiet Montauk Harbor area is just a five-minute walk from the harbor’s bars and restaurants. Just across the street is a beautiful beach that tends to be very quiet. Bright and modern rooms…
          28. The Montauk Soundview Resort Hotel
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            The Montauk Soundview Resort Hotel is a cozy and quiet mid-range property sitting right on Napeague Bay. The hotel offers a relaxed, self-catering stay away from the crowds, but within a five-minute walk of the restaurants and shops near famous Gosman's Dock. The 23 apartments and cottages have full…
          29. Kenny's Tipperary Inn
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            The two-and-a-half-pearl Kenny’s Tipperary Inn offers charming and tidy accommodations for a relatively affordable price in Montauk. It isn't within walking distance of the town center or any major hotspots, but it's in a peaceful location about a five-minute walk to Lake Montauk and to the Block -…
          30. Topping Rose House
            Bridgehampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Boutique
            • Historic
            • Luxury
            • Romantic
            A luxury haven in the heart of the Hamptons, this boutique beauty seamlessly blends together the old and the new. Housed in a circa 1842 Greek Revival mansion, the restored and fully updated hot spot hotel features 16 spacious guest rooms, six one-bedroom Suites, a restaurant by celebrity chef an to…
          31. Hampton Maid
            Hampton Bays, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Bed and Breakfast/Inn
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Historic
            • Romantic
            A four-generation family business, the Hampton Maid is a charming mid-range property on a hillside overlooking Shinnecock Bay. The 29 cottage-style rooms are bright and clean with individualized decor, wooden decks, and sleek mini-fridges. Locals and guests flock to the on-site restaurant for its a…
          32. Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead
            Riverhead, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Business
            • Child-Friendly
            The Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead is a comfortable, three-pearl property located across the street from the popular Tanger Outlets. The contemporary hotel has an attractive amenities package that includes a full-service restaurant/bar, laundry room, fitness center, indoor pool/whirlpool, and 22-person…
          33. Bridgehampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Value
            This basic 10-room motel provides budget accommodations in an expensive area of eastern Long Island. The biggest draw here is the close proximity to Bridgehampton and nearby beaches. Rooms are uninteresting and starting to show wear and tear, but the front porches, outdoor pool, and a pretty lawn If…
          34. Southampton Village Motel
            Southampton, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Value
            The Southampton Village Motel is a bright and fresh budget property with a convenient location and a quiet atmosphere. The restaurants and shops of Main Street are a 10-minute walk away while beaches are within a short drive or bike ride. Renovated in 2014, the 10 rooms feature air-conditioning, and…
          35. West Neck Guesthouse
            Hamptons, Long Island, New York
            • Bed and Breakfast/Inn
            The West Neck Guesthouse is located on Shelter Island, across the street from a nine-hole golf course and a short drive from the beach or the north ferry pier. It's a simple bed-and-breakfast with six rooms decorated in bright coastal decor, with iPod docks, mini-fridges, and coffeemakers. Half the…
          36. Aqualina Inn Montauk
            Montauk, Hamptons, Long Island
            • Value
            Aqualina Inn Montauk is a laid-back seasonal budget inn geared toward beachgoers. Situated between the beach and downtown Montauk, it's only a few minutes' walk from each. Highlights of the hotel include an outdoor pool surrounded by loungers and a central courtyard with picnic tables and grills. -…
          37. Cliffside Resort Condominiums
          38. Breakers MTK
          39. Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End
          40. Windward Shores
          41. Shelter Island House
          42. Sound View Greenport
          43. Sun 'N' Sound
          44. The Blue Inn At North Fork
          45. Southampton Inn
          46. The Hamlet Inn

          Don't Forget to Like Us On Facebook! We Love to Be Liked.