Oyster Pearl Rating

  • Award-Winning

What's Your Style?

    See More

    Locations

      See More

      Amenities

        See More

        Sanibel Island Hotels

          18 Hotels Found
          1. Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            Sundial Beach Resort & Spa is a well-kept, three-and-a-half-pearl property located on a private Sanibel Island beachfront. The resort’s 206 condo-style units are individually owned, which means decor standards can be inconsistent from room to room, but most are bright and contemporary and all full…
          2. Casa Ybel Resort
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Historic
            • Romantic
            These 114 beachfront condos are part time-share and part Hilton property. The sprawling resort is set in the middle of the southern Sanibel coast and is considered one of the more upscale locations on the island, though there have been some remarks that the amenities don't quite fit the price point…
          3. Sanibel Moorings Resort
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            Nestled between the Gulf of Mexico and a quiet canal, this mid-range, six-acre Sanibel Island resort is blanketed in tropical botanical gardens and sits on a prime shelling beach. All of the 122 condo-style suites are individually owned, so each has its own style and decor. Some units overlook the a…
          4. West Wind Inn
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            Set along West Gulf Drive in an area that combines residences and hotels in vegetation-ensconced grounds, upper-mid-range West Wind Inn combines the ‘70s charm of an old Sanibel property with renovated rooms featuring vaguely colonial decor. The inn is a comfortable, unassuming property with direct…
          5. Song of the Sea
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            The simple grounds here, dotted with pastel pink, two-story stucco buildings, are straight out of the ‘80s. The 30 mid-range guest units with their linoleum countertops are no less so, though there’s still a charming, understated elegance to the rooms. Song of the Sea has direct access to the beach…
          6. Sunset Beach Inn
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            This mid-range beachfront property offers small guest units at reasonable prices near the water, along with an outdoor pool and free beach gear to borrow. Don’t expect a luxury spot, and there have been a moderate number of complaints about insufficient deep cleaning in rooms, particularly of and of…
          7. Seahorse Cottages
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Value
            Sanibel Island's Seahorse Cottages is a budget boutique hotel with just four cottages and typically limited availability. The cottages are nestled in a quiet area of Old Town Sanibel, just 200 feet from the beach -- it's a great place to get away from the hustle and bustle. Cottages all have full is…
          8. Seaside Inn
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            The old Florida charm of this property draws guests seeking a simple stay. The inn's 32 clean, plain rooms with small outdoor areas outside of sliding glass doors are laid out in one- and two-story clapboard buildings with wood walkways and railings. The modest hotel, situated towards the eastern of…
          9. Sanibel Inn
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            Situated at the eastern end of Sanibel, less than a mile from the causeway bridge to the mainland, the 93 rooms here all offer condo-style living a few hundred feet from the sand. Comfortable beds and free bike loans -- as well as a heated outdoor pool -- are all special draws at this casual which a…
          10. Beachview Cottages
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            Location is a big draw at Beachview Cottages, which sits a few hundred feet from white sand in the middle of a small island, a short drive from the stores on Tarpon Bay Road. The 40-year-old property retains bare-foot appeal through its collection of 22 airy, standalone bungalows with wood laminate…
          11. Castaways Cottages of Sanibel
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Boutique
            • Child-Friendly
            • Historic
            This rustic, mid-range property, set on a narrow strip of land between Sanibel and Captiva islands and on an active marina, consists of simple, standalone cottages. Some of the full kitchenettes are set directly next to Sanibel Captiva Road, which guests have noted can generate steady, if not The in…
          12. Shalimar Cottages and Motel
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            Set on a pristinely maintained property, the 33-room Shalimar Cottages and Motel is a budget beachfront property composed of, as its name suggests, a motel and several quaint cottages. There’s a lovely outdoor pool surrounded by lounge chairs and shaded tables, as well as a picnic area with The also…
          13. Waterside Inn on the Beach
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Romantic
            The 27-room Waterside Inn on the Beach has a large variety of rooms and caters to those looking for mid-range digs with kitchens and easy beach access. Units here vary quite a bit, from rooms with microwaves and fridges to cottages and condos. There's a heated pool at the center of the grounds, and…
          14. Sanibel Island Beach Resort
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            With 98 rooms and lots of on-site amenities, the three-pearl Sanibel Island Beach Resort is one of Sanibel's larger and better equipped hotels. Rooms and suites are available; the latter come with kitchenettes and living rooms with sofa beds. The property includes a tennis court, a heated outdoor an…
          15. Tropical Winds Motel & Cottages
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            The budget Tropical Winds Motel & Cottages offers a slice of old-fashioned Floridian charm on a peaceful stretch of sand with ample shelling opportunities. The simple property has a lovely outdoor pool, plus other conveniences that include laundry facilities and bike rentals. The 10 pleasant, if and…
          16. Anchor Inn & Cottages
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Bed and Breakfast/Inn
            • Child-Friendly
            • Value
            Anchor Inn & Cottages is a cheery, two-pearl property located on Sanibel Island. The property’s nine inn rooms are basic but tidy, offering practical kitchenettes or full kitchens, while the three cottages amp up the charm with their eye-catching A-frame roofs (although decor could use an update in…
          17. Blue Dolphin Cottages
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            The nine-unit Blue Dolphin Cottages is an ideal mid-range choice for couples and families who want a quiet, no-fuss, beachside location with self-catering facilities. Most of the rooms and apartments here have kitchens, and all come with free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and private patios. The grounds a…
          18. Sanibel Siesta on the Beach
            Sanibel Island, Southwest Gulf Coast, Florida
            • Beachfront
            • Child-Friendly
            • Romantic
            • Value
            The 56-room Sanibel Siesta on the Beach is a mid-range condo rental property with a wonderful garden area and direct beach access. The two-bedroom, two-bathroom condos offer full kitchens, screened-in porches with seating, and attached private garages. Some offer dazzling ocean views and have steel…

          Like Us on Facebook! We Make Your Day Better with Gorgeous Pics